For the preschool, kindergarten age group, the lessons the games are reinforcing are limited. They pretty much stick to the following categories:
- alphabet (identifying letters and sounds)
- numbers (counting, simple adding and subtracting)
- shapes
- colors
- memory
- spot the difference
One thing I can verify from personal experience is these games do entertain. If I would let her, Sage would play computer games all night. I always limit her game playing, and she never tires of it before I tell her to shut it down. So, the game makers have that part right, they know how to reel the kids in and keep them in. At this age, the kids should need the parents’ permission, and since the games are advertised as being educational, that reels the parents in. What I want to know is, is their claim valid? Is Sage actually learning anything from playing these games? My honest opinion, I think she is, but I want to prove it.
In order to prove that Sage is in fact learning something from these games I need to find a game she has never played before (that’s easy) but I also need it to teach her something she doesn’t already know. She knows how to count, and her alphabet. She getting better at adding and subtracting, what doesn’t she know how to do? Well, she can’t read yet. So, I have found a game that teaches the words of colors by sight. I am going to use this game exclusively to try to teach her how to identify the words red, yellow, green etc. I will log the amount of time she spends playing this game. At the same time, I am going to teach her how to read the words of numbers (one, two, three etc.) I will do this using a more traditional approach, paper and pen or chalk and a chalkboard. I will then compare and see what she can better recognize. I will keep you posted on the progress and post the final results in one month.
It will be interesting to see if your daughters' generation of girls will be more or less inlvolved in gaming as they grow older. My experience with older kids is still, as research supports, that boys spend more time gaming than girls. Great topic. It ties into my questions about gender and IT so I will certainly watch for informtation that may be useful to you. Laura
ReplyDeleteHi Kim
ReplyDeleteI ran across a similar article to this one (http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/brain-training-games-do-not-improve-mental-skills-study-says-1949605.html) a few seeks ago. It deals specifically with "brain training games" but it may be of interest or at least lead you to other interesting studies.
Dean
Laura, I'm really curious about the gender differences too. I am in the IT field and I personally see a lot of difference just in the interests between me and my co-workers. I don't know about the younger generation though, comparing Sage to her boy cousin of the same age, she's more into computer games then he is, but it could just be a difference in personalities at this point too.
ReplyDelete